i'm very sorry yall are in such a jam, and I do hope you'll get someone who can deal with that.
Have you tried calling or contacting goodwill directly ? If you'll look them up online, you'll find they have regional main offices. I contacted one near here, through the "contact us" email, which went right to the regional office, and got an almost immediate response from the regional director, confirming that they (and all the north tx and south ok area goodwill stores) accepted crt monitors. Possibly (and hopefully) yours will as well, and could even possibly arrange for a pickup of so many?
Bookmarks