Sounds like maybe you should call around and see if there is one you don't know about, or at least get pricing from the other 2. From reading on SMF I was convinced to try a yard other than the one I use regularly and I was not impressed either. One in the same town almost assuredly sells to the bigger one I already go to and one the next town over has similar pricing but doesn't take half the stuff (mostly e-waste) my main yard does. We all have to just make the best of what's available and keep an eye out for ways to make more than scrap or more for scrap.
Bookmarks