Originally Posted by
ScrappinRed
Even with a clear "no return" policy and selling items "as-is" Ebay allowed a buyer to return 2 separate listings he bought from me because he said I should have taken higher resolution pictures and listed every single scratch, nick, scuff, and mark in the description. I had 12 high resolution photos showing these boards from all sides, and the zoom feature was available on all of them. These were 35 year old boards and clearly sold untested, as-is, no returns.
Not only did Ebay take the money out of my Paypal account as soon as delivery confirmation uploaded, but they allowed him to leave 2 negative feedbacks about me having "deceptive photos with too much flash." I wasn't even given time to inspect the items to make sure they were in the original condition I sent them out in.
So no, it actually doesn't really matter what your policy is, Ebay will give a refund for whatever reason they please. I was on the phone for half an hour with customer service and they said there was nothing they could do. They said if I had included close up photos of the particular discoloration that this fellow was mad about, then I wouldn't have to return them. They didn't care that the lot included 4 boards, and there were clear photos of all areas of the boards that could be enlarged.
These items were returned 3.5 weeks after their purchase. When I start having returns 6 months after a sale, I will definitely be rethinking Ebay...