Originally Posted by
Ditchdigger
Oh I agree 100% that you can't predict for certain how the kid is going to turn out by the way they are parented. And it works the other way too. I know one guy, that I used to work with, who is one of four siblings. Two convicted felons and one dead from a drug overdose, and he's as stable and hardworking as they come. I'm sure his parents didn't decide to raise him right and let the other three run wild.
That's why I'm giving this dad as much of the benefit of the doubt as I can. Note that I did say this might have been the perfect thing for the situation, and that all I really did was question, and ask everybody else to question, the thing in it's entireity before crowning him, because we don't know anything more about her than he shares with us, and we don't know anything more about him than we see in the video.
If you want to get into it in a little more detail, I'll tell you where I think his approach is flawed.
First, I'm 100% on board with him calling her on the foul language, disrespectful tone, whining about her responsibilities around the house, and posting it all so the parents couldn't see it. She comes off as a spoiled brat, and it's her own words that paint that picture of her. (And again, I question whether better parenting might've led to a less spoiled kid, but since we're in agreement that the outcome is never certain, let's move on.)
(Also, I have two 7 year olds here, and a handful of older ones with my ex. I've had my fair share of "I hate you!" thrown at me for my own unpopular rulings, and my response is, "If you don't hate me from time to time, I'm not doing my job right.")
What I have a problem with is that he chooses the internet as his venue to strike back, one, because he's now given up the parental, adult, high ground, and sunk to her level, and two, because he fails to realize the potential for his rant to go viral, so his kid and their domestic stress is now being discussed by a bunch of scrappers, and God knows who else. You think years from now the two of them are going to sit down together and laugh at the time Daddy shot the **** out of her laptop on YouTube? No matter how good or bad she turns out, I think it's going to take a whole lot of forgiving on her part to deal with the now public nature of this, and I hope for his sake she's capable of that.
Also, I'm 100% on board with denying her the computer, and further access to Facebook, for some period of time. Maybe some loooong period of time. Let the punishment fit the crime.
I do have a real problem though, with the whole way he goes about it. 'I'm now going to shoot holes in your computer with this very powerful handgun, with this very expensive and deadly ammunition, and I'm going to charge you for each round.'
(Hey, don't the Russians, and some others in the third world charge the families of those they execute for the bullets? I've always thought Americans took a dim view of **** like that, but I guess it's ok here in family disputes. But I digress...)
I dunno, it just seems to me like that whole part of it was way over the top. Don't we try to teach our kids not to "act out" on their anger? Yet here's a Dad demonstrating just that. The use of lethal force, on a computer.
And finally, back to the posting of it on the internet. He says right out that she may never get to see the video, since the computer's now dead. So, where's the communication, father to daughter? That's probably what made me most question why she's the way she is. Has she spent 15 years trying to interpret his actions, or third party communications, as opposed to him communicating in a more straightforward fashion, parent to child?
You guys may think he's Father of the Year. Maybe he is. I'll hold my vote for someone I have fewer questions about though...