Any reason a buyer identifying brass would use a Gold silver Acid test to confirm

Hi I've been scrapping a couple times a month now for a couple of years. Recently I took some brass and copper items for scrap. Among the items were internal parts coming from the internals of either defense electronics or electronic testing and calibration units that had once been gone trough for the tubes and transistors. While taking much of this stuff apart I could not help but be amazed by the high degree of precision construction. If there were moving gears or rods they were usually made of machined brass and maybe use some stainless steel bearings.

One piece which was a Silver in color from surface and trough out its construction. It was rectangular housing for other moving rods and gears which measured approximately 6" long x 4" Width x 1 1/4" depth and having approximately a 1/4" thick walls. I simply wasn't sure what it was made of but the machining was immaculate and the weight of it was impressive. Over 3 lbs.

I held the item separate and it was the last thing I gave the buyer telling him, I am not sure what this is. So he takes the item over to the grinding wheel and grinds it. Just as I have seen and witnessed many buyers do to identify brass items. But in this case after he put it on the grinding wheel he kind of got a funny look on him and then walked over to his desk and performed a liquid acid test on it. Then he turned and said, Wow you got one heavy piece of brass here. I asked is that what it is because I was not sure, he stated yep its one heavy piece of brass. I got approximately $4.10 for it.

But I couldn't help notice the feeling in my gut, that the whole exchange just seemed odd. I have never seen a buyer go beyond using a grinder and need to take a potential piece of brass and perform an acid test on it to say it was brass.

Is there a brass used that is silver through and through? Would a acid test determine if something was brass? Would there be a reason that a experienced scrap metal buyer would need or want to use a acid test after a grinding wheel to identify something as being brass? Or if you were to grind silver or even platinum would it be fairly obvious and therefore create a need to perform an acid test on it to confirm an expert buyers suspicions. Is it possible that I gave away over 3 lbs of silver that would have been worth over $700? or even worse if by chance it would have been platinum?



I realize its to little to late and that I made a critical mistake in not having it tested or witnessing the testing of the piece. I am just curious to have some experienced scrappers give me their answers to my questions. Thanks!