After reading people's opinions, the one thing I will change is I will get them in one trip. One trip to get them and one trip to pay and give the metal back.
I will factor in my mileage
Still think the 50/50 is fair. I know he's paid $1 for each one so don't think he would go any more. Also I don't have to give any money up front so no worrying about prices.
I do have a lot of time built up at my work so I will take a paid week off. Should be able to tear the scrap one's down easy enough in a week. He also has a partial pallet of just boards so that also helps.
Bookmarks